Digital public services in the Netherlands often assume that citizens can navigate online portals, find and interpret information, understand complex letters, and spot mistakes made by the administration. Drawing on interviews with professionals who help people deal with public authorities, this blogpost shows what happens when citizens cannot meet these expectations. Too often, they are expected to acquire the missing skills or find help themselves, giving rise to a “responsive citizen” model, which stands in contrast with the notion of the “responsive state”.
Introduction
Low-income households in the Netherlands lose an average of €300 a month in benefits because of complex administrative requirements, according to NL Times. Underlying this figure lies the question: who is responsible for ensuring that people can effectively access public services and claim their rights?
The Dutch public sector is among the most digitalised in Europe. Most services are accessed through online portals using DigiD, the national digital identity system. Yet having a legal entitlement does not necessarily mean being able to exercise it. Access increasingly presupposes a range of digital, informational and literacy skills. Without them, the right to social security risks remaining theoretical, even though the Netherlands has undertaken under Article 12 of the European Social Charter to maintain a social security system “with a view to ensuring the effective exercise” of that right.
In a recent article in Information Polity, I argue that digitalisation has not made the state more responsive to its citizens. Instead, citizens have increasingly had to become responsive to the state’s demands.
Studying access through intermediaries
To understand where citizens get stuck, I turned to those who help them. Between March 2024 and January 2025, I conducted 16 semi-structured interviews with professionals who support citizens in their dealings with public authorities. Most were counsellors (sociaal raadslieden), who provide legal and financial advice on benefits, taxes, debts and objections to administrative decisions. The sample also included social workers, a lawyer at a municipality and experts on systemic issues in Dutch public services.
I interviewed professionals rather than citizens because their work brings them into contact with many people over extended periods, allowing them to identify recurring structural patterns rather than isolated experiences. However, this approach also has limitations: the findings reflect professional perspectives, not citizens’ own accounts. I analysed the interviews through thematic coding and abductive reasoning.
What the digital state expects
“You have to be digitally skilled. You need to be able to do math,” one participant explained. “And often, people lack one of those skills. Or they have none of them, that happens too.”
Dealing with bureaucracy has always required some ability to read, understand and complete forms. Digitalisation has not created this demand, but it has narrowed the ways people can compensate when they struggle to meet it. As service counters close and face-to-face contact recedes, fewer avenues remain for asking questions or resolving difficulties. The interviews identified four key expectations that digital administration places on citizens.
Digital literacy. Non-digital alternatives may formally exist, but they are often difficult to find in systems designed around digital access. Some citizens lack a smartphone, a computer or a DigiD account. Even when authorities write by post, citizens typically have to log in with their DigiD to respond. One counsellor for instance described elderly clients struggling with text-message codes, passwords and usernames: “That’s a bit too much for them.”
Information literacy. Information may be available online without being easy to find. “Click, click, click – somewhere in there,” as one counsellor put it. People who cannot locate the relevant information may miss out on entitlements, including tax waivers or remissions. Furthermore, knowing that a right exists is not the same as knowing how to claim it.
Functional literacy. Roughly one in nine people in the Netherlands experiences difficulties with reading and writing, while official correspondence often uses complex written language. Shame can make matters worse: some people conceal their difficulties even from their partners and children, making it less likely that they will seek support.
Spotting and avoiding mistakes. Citizens must not only provide accurate information but also detect errors made by the administration. In one case from the interviews, a mother and daughter were wrongly registered as partners in the allowance system. Although the error was corrected, it resurfaced in subsequent years. Thus, administrative errors may persist despite correction, yet citizens’ own mistakes can have serious consequences: an unreported change in income or an incorrectly ticked box can trigger repayment claims years later and push households into debt.
When skills fall short: respond or be left behind
What happens when citizens cannot meet these expectations? The interviews point to two common responses: they must either acquire the missing skills or find help independently.
The first option is to learn. Public libraries, often funded by or working with municipalities, offer free courses such as Klik & Tik and Digisterker. These initiatives can be valuable, but they assume that people have the time and energy to participate. As one participant observed, someone juggling work, family, health problems and debts has “no space in your life to go to school weekly and do homework”.
The second option is to seek help. Support may be available from counsellors, libraries, family and friends, but accessing it can itself be difficult. “First, asking for help is already hard. And second, actually walking through the door” is even harder, one counsellor noted. Others described people who were “too busy surviving” to seek support, or who distrusted government and preferred to stay off its radar. Counsellors also reported long waiting lists for their services, showing high demand from citizens.
Interestingly, not all interviewees viewed self-reliance (zelfredzaamheid) negatively. Building citizens’ skills can be empowering, and self-reliance is also an objective of the Dutch Social Support Act 2015. The problem arises when self-reliance ceases to be a goal and becomes a precondition for exercising rights.
From the responsive state to the responsive citizen
The idea of a responsive state starts from the premise that all human beings are vulnerable and rely on social institutions throughout their lives. Furthermore, it depicts that state becomes responsive to the needs and demands of its citizens. The opposing model, the restrained state, often associated with neoliberal governance, takes the autonomous, fully capable individual as its benchmark and overlooks the inequalities embedded in the systems in which people live.
In line with the model of the restrained state, the empirical findings point to the emergence of the responsive citizen. This concept captures a novel dynamic in which citizens are expected to respond to the demands and expectations of public authorities by bridging the gap between their own capabilities and the requirements of the system. As noted, this may involve acquiring new skills or seeking assistance in order to access public services and exercise their rights.
The dynamic is cyclical, illustrated in figure 1. The administration sets expectations about the skills needed to access a service. Those who meet them can proceed, while those who do not must find ways to adapt. Because digital systems and procedures keep changing, the citizen’s responsiveness is never complete: each new portal or procedure can bring new demands, and the cycle starts again.
The responsive-citizen concept builds on research on responsibilisation (e.g. Clarke; Schou and Hjelholt; Tonkens) and on scholarship on digital administrative burdens (e.g. Herd and Moynihan, Peeters). What it adds is a specific mechanism: responsibility for access itself has shifted from the administration to the individual. Responsiveness has grown, but it is citizens who are expected to provide it.
Figure 1:

Towards a responsive administration
The conceptual framework of the responsive citizen can also serve as a diagnostic tool. Every service requires some skills. Problems arise when those requirements go beyond what can reasonably be expected of the people who rely on the service, and no accessible alternative is available.
A responsive administration would act proactively rather than reactively. It would reduce complexity, intervene early, and adapt to the capabilities of its population instead of expecting the reverse. In practice, this could mean human-centred interfaces, flexible multichannel service delivery, and information on entitlements that reaches people unprompted and that they can understand. Free digital literacy courses at local libraries may be well intentioned, but they illustrate how policy can overlook citizens’ lived realities. Rather than adapting services to people’s needs, they expect citizens to adapt to the system. This also means that people must invest time and resources before they can access their rights. Furthermore, administrations need structured, ongoing dialogue with frontline professionals, who see where policy intentions and citizens’ experiences diverge.
Wherever services become digital by default, and the distance between citizen and state grows as face-to-face contact declines, the same question arises: does the administration adapt to its citizens, or must citizens adapt to it? Access to public services, and through them to fundamental rights, should not be a privilege of a few but a guarantee for all.
Malou Beck is a PhD candidate at Tilburg Law School, researching how the digitalisation of public services creates and deepens administrative vulnerabilities in the Dutch welfare state. Her doctoral research is part of the NWO-funded project “Vulnerability in the Digital Administrative State,” led by Prof. Sofia Ranchordás.


